A picture-postcard Key West cottage.

Living in a charming cottage—on a hidden lane in Old Town—is an aspiration of many a Key West connoisseur. Nestled between two quiet lanes, 1112 Elgin Lane is just the quintessential Key West cottage to make one’s dream come true.

We love the original Dade County pine walls.

Built in 1899, and originally owned by three generations of spongers, this picturesque home has been beautifully restored to retain its historic appeal. You will love the white picket fence, front porch swing, and classic gingerbread details. Dade County pine walls, wood floors, and multiple windows greet you as you enter the inviting living room. You will be captivated by the spacious second floor master bedroom with its exposed beams and en suite bath. The attractive new kitchen features state-of-the-art appliances and opens to covered outdoor dining and lovely garden views. Parking is a delight with a gated carport off Stickney Lane.

The light-filled master suite.

Tucked away in the heart of Old Town— just a short stroll from Island House and the Historic Seaport—1112 Elgin Lane is ideally located. Enjoy the quaint neighborhood feel of small-town life, embrace the island’s big-city amenities, and experience your Key West dream in this very special island home.

Keith & Dean

Click here to enjoy a virtual tour of this charming Key West cottage.